Évaluation formative par les pairs, expertise et légitimation de l’insulte.
Quand les experts se mettent à insulter
Article
Jérémy IANNI, associate research fellow at IRASEC has published an article in the journal Sociographe. For the special issue titled “Insults and Slander : Lessons from Impropriety,” edited by Pierre Bechler and Nordine Ahmed Touil, he reflects on his experience as a doctoral student, which he analyzes from epistemological and educational perspectives.
Abstract
Peer review is a formative process in which insulting and humiliating remarks may arise, particularly when it is misused or taken out of context. In such cases, it becomes a means of legitimizing insults, drawing on the figure of the expert, the protection of the purity of knowledge, and the denial of the uniqueness of the name.
19 November 2026






